When a household moves beyond the standard commuter vehicle and the practical family SUV, the criteria for choosing a “third car” shift dramatically. It is no longer about cargo space or fuel efficiency for the daily grind; it is about purely the joy of driving.
Automotive enthusiast and YouTuber Doug DeMuro suggests that the ideal third vehicle should meet four specific pillars: it must be reliable, relatively modern, affordable, and fun to drive. However, the “right” choice ultimately depends on your personal lifestyle—specifically your available garage space, disposable income, and how much time you can actually dedicate to driving.
The Top Contenders: Six Picks for Enthusiasts
Based on DeMuro’s recommendations, here are six vehicles that offer distinct flavors of performance and engagement.
1. The High-Value Performer: Chevrolet Corvette Z06 (C6)
The C6 Corvette Z06 stands out as a masterclass in “bang for your buck.” With a massive 7.0-liter V8 producing 505 hp, it offers supercar-level performance without the supercar price tag.
– Estimated Price: ~$33,640 (2006 model)
– Why it works: It is relatively inexpensive to maintain, doesn’t require a massive garage, and remains incredibly engaging behind the wheel.
2. The Raw Antidote: Dodge Viper
If your daily commute involves a boring, silent sedan, the Dodge Viper is the ultimate cure. This is a loud, aggressive, and unapologetic machine.
– Estimated Price: ~$57,500 (2003 SRT)
– The Experience: Powered by an 8.3-liter V10, the Viper is designed for those who want a visceral, high-intensity connection to the road.
3. The Pure Driver’s Tool: Mazda MX-5 Miata (ND)
Not every enthusiast needs raw horsepower to have fun. The ND Miata focuses on agility and communication.
– Estimated Price: $26,650 – $35,925 (2019 model)
– Why it works: Known for its communicative steering and exceptional handling, the Miata is perfect for those who prioritize finesse and lightweight responsiveness over brute force.
4. The Exotic Daily: Mercedes-AMG GT
For those who prefer German engineering and a more sophisticated aesthetic, the AMG GT is a standout. Notably, it is the only automatic vehicle on this list, making it more accessible for varied driving conditions.
– Estimated Price: ~$65,003 (2019 model)
– The Edge: DeMuro notes that despite its exotic appearance and 630 hp V8, it is surprisingly reliable and relatively affordable to own compared to its peers.
5. The Precision Instrument: Porsche 981 Boxster Cayman S
Porsche is synonymous with driving dynamics, and the 981 generation is highly regarded for its balance.
– Estimated Price: ~$47,993 (2013 model)
– The Experience: With a 3.4-liter 6-cylinder engine, this car is celebrated for its exceptional engineering and the “fun factor” inherent in its mid-engine layout.
6. The Modern Icon: Toyota Supra
The newer generation of the Supra offers a blend of modern technology and turbocharged performance.
– Estimated Price: ~$57,998 (2022 model)
– The Specs: Featuring a 3.0-liter turbo inline-6 producing 382 hp, it represents a more contemporary choice for those wanting a high-tech driving experience.
Summary of Key Specifications
| Vehicle | Engine Type | Horsepower | Est. Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Corvette Z06 | 7.0L V8 | 505 hp | ~$33,640 |
| Dodge Viper | 8.3L V10 | 500 hp | ~$57,500 |
| Mazda Miata | 2.0L I4 | 181 hp | ~$26,650+ |
| Mercedes AMG GT | 4.0L V8 | 630 hp | ~$65,003 |
| Porsche Cayman S | 3.4L H6 | 315 hp | ~$47,993 |
| Toyota Supra | 3.0L I6 Turbo | 382 hp | ~$57,998 |
The Bottom Line: Whether you seek the raw aggression of a Viper or the nimble precision of a Miata, a third car should serve as a reward—a vehicle that turns a simple drive into an experience.
