For budget-conscious buyers, used cars offer significant savings compared to new vehicles – the average used car costs $25,512, while a new one averages $48,841. However, price isn’t the only factor; reliability is crucial. Investing in a durable vehicle ensures long-term value and avoids costly repairs.
This guide highlights six used car models with a proven track record of longevity, based on data from Consumer Reports, iSeeCars, and CarGurus. These vehicles have a higher-than-average chance of exceeding 250,000 miles and are frequently kept by their original owners for 15 years or more.
Honda Ridgeline
Starting Price: $29,019
Longevity: 25.8% chance of reaching 250,000+ miles (three times the average)
Owner Retention: 5.5% of owners keep the vehicle for 15+ years
Reliability Rank: No. 4
Toyota Avalon
Starting Price: $17,890
Longevity: 22% chance of reaching 250,000+ miles (2.5 times the average)
Reliability Rank: No. 2
Honda Pilot
Starting Price: $26,377
Longevity: 17.5% chance of reaching 250,000+ miles (two times the average)
Owner Retention: 5% of owners keep the vehicle for 15+ years
Reliability Rank: No. 4
Toyota Highlander
Starting Price: $28,866
Longevity: 15.7% chance of reaching 250,000+ miles (1.8 times the average)
Owner Retention: 6.6% of owners keep the vehicle for 15+ years
Reliability Rank: No. 2
Toyota Prius
Starting Price: $15,146
Longevity: 12.6% chance of reaching 250,000+ miles (1.5 times the average)
Owner Retention: 6.3% of owners keep the vehicle for 15+ years
Reliability Rank: No. 2
Mazda CX-9
Starting Price: $23,410
Longevity: 12.4% chance of reaching 250,000+ miles (1.4 times the average)
Owner Retention: 4.3% of owners keep the vehicle for 15+ years
Reliability Rank: No. 3
Methodology: This list is based on a compilation of data from Consumer Reports (reliability rankings), iSeeCars (vehicles likely to exceed 250,000 miles), and CarGurus (accurate pricing as of October 1, 2025). The analysis considers both long-term reliability and owner retention rates, indicating vehicles that are both durable and well-loved.
Choosing a reliable used car is a smart financial decision, offering long-term value and peace of mind. The models listed above consistently outperform the average in terms of longevity and owner satisfaction
